While reviewing First Solar’s first quarter earnings, we were surprised by the dramatic rise in receivables on a decline in revenue. The company generated revenue of $418 million, down four percent sequentially, while its accounts receivable balance rose 300 percent, from $60 million to about $180 million. This had a substantial negative effect on the company’s cash flows. Since cash received from customers was down $100 million (25 percent) on a sequential basis, FSLR had net negative cash flows for the quarter. In addition, the company’s tax rate fell from 23 percent in the fourth quarter of 2008 to three percent in Q1 on a one-time Malaysian tax refund. This gave the company a $0.15 boost to its bottom line.
First Solar chose to extend the payment terms for its customers from 10 days to 45 days in the most recent quarter, giving the customers more flexibility in light of heightened uncertainty and credit difficulty in the solar industry. As a result, the company’s DSOs nearly tripled in the first quarter of 2009. We see this as evidence that FSLR’s customers are having increasing difficulty obtaining funds and maintaining liquidity, as well as potentially having working capital issues. This dramatic rise in receivables also raises the specter of write-downs and bad debt expense in the future. We also think that the company will burn cash at a faster rate going forward since it is receiving substantially less cash from customers. The company continues to invest in expanding its Malaysian plant capacity and financing large German solar projects, which will require continuous funding.
Though First Solar beat estimates for the first quarter of 2009, we think that it has hit a brick wall based on its receivables soaring 300 percent on a decline in revenues and its bottom line being artificially boosted by a one-time Malaysian tax refund. Because of these issues, we have concerns about the quality of First Solar’s Q1 earnings.
